5 Best Roofing Companies in Lancaster PA Compared
Lancaster homeowners have no shortage of roofing contractors to choose from.
The difficult decision is determining what kind of company you need for the job: a small leak, storm damage, worn out shingle roof, whole exterior project or a home that requires a contractor that specializes in Lancaster County homes.
The right contractor choice is about local experience, how big their services are, communication, fit for your project and explanation of the work before starting.
This competitive analysis reviews five roofing companies that operate in the Lancaster area. For the overall homeowner Roof Duck came out on top as the company to consider if looking for a well-established local company with extensive residential roofing and exterior solutions.
In This Guide
- Quick comparison
- Roof Duck
- Joyland Roofing
- The Exterior Company
- Greenawalt Roofing
- MR Roofing
- How to choose a Lancaster roofer
- Final verdict
Quick Comparison
| Company | Best for | Roofing focus | Other exterior services |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roof Duck | Best overall local choice when hiring residential contractors | Inspections, repairs, replacements | Siding, gutters |
| Joyland Roofing | Clear process to follow | Repairs and roof replacements | Siding, gutters, windows and doors |
| The Exterior Company | Large storm and exterior work | Residential/commercial roofing | Complete siding, gutters, storm repairs |
| Greenawalt Roofing | Residential & commercial property owners | Roofing & storm restoration services | Siding, gutters |
| MR Roofing | Detail oriented roof installation | New roofs and roof replacements | Roofing-specific specialties |
Lancaster consumers should make sure any home improvement contractor they hire is registered in Pennsylvania. According to Pennsylvania’s Business One-Stop Shop, home improvement contractors must register for the appropriate HIC registration.
1. Roof Duck: Best Overall for Long-Standing Local Experience
Roof Duck is not their original name. Roof Duck is a roofing company based out of Lancaster County that has been in business since 1947. They went by the name of Brubaker Bros. Roofing but have since changed their name. Roof Duck is located in Manheim and provides services to Lancaster and other areas of Central PA.
That history gives Roof Duck a distinctive position in this group.
The business offers residential roof inspections, roof repair and replacement, as well as siding and gutter services. This means homeowners who seek premier roofing specialists have one contractor that can evaluate the roof and manage associated exterior work.
Strong local ties and branches provide widespread residential services.
Roof Duck features manufacturer credentials from companies such as GAF, CertainTeed on its current site as well. Roofing pages concentrate on inspection based recommendations, costs of labor/material by region and walking homeowners through their options before any work is performed.
That can be beneficial for a homeowner who has discovered a leak following a storm, but isn’t sure if a repair or replacement is in order. Instead of beginning with an idea of a project, the process starts with the condition of the roof.
Establishment as a local roofing company for many years is also corroborated by information available through the company BBB profile. There, it is indicated that this business started in 1947 and is a BBB-accredited roofing contractor with an A+ rating.
Best suited to: Homeowners throughout Lancaster looking for a locally grown contractor for residential roofing, siding or gutter installation who like having one company for all their exterior needs.
2. Joyland Roofing: Best for a Structured Homeowner Process
Website about Joyland Roofing who provides roof replacement, roof repair as well as other exterior services in Lancaster and surrounding counties.
Their website describes an uncomplicated process centered on inspection, preparation and execution. Their site also features inspection photos and videos, easy project communication and a payment structure that pushes payment until after completion for residential projects.
That process orientation is the clearest reason Joyland earns a place here.
Communication, cleanup and responsiveness also come up over and over again in recent customer reviews. Angi’s current Joyland Roofing reviews feature multiple mentions of timely service, effective communication and clean work areas.
For homeowners who worry about what occurs from estimate to cleanup, that kind of schedule can provide peace of mind.
Best suited to: homeowners who value communication, thorough inspection and a clearly explained project timeline.
3. The Exterior Company: Best for Storm and Multi-Service Projects
The Exterior Company in Lancaster offers residential and commercial roofing services. They do inspections, repairs and replacements along with storm damage repairs.
Its area of expertise is wider than a small residential-only roofing contractor. They also do siding and gutters. They boast about having project managers.
It also makes it a viable solution when roofing is just one portion of an extensive exterior restoration.
Take for instance a home that incurs damage from wind or hail. Perhaps the roof needs repairs in addition to needing siding or gutter work. The ability to utilize those services from one contractor lessens the need to manage multiple companies.
The company is featured in several Lancaster roofing roundups being put together currently such as Expertise.com’s Lancaster roofer comparison article which showcases just how competitive the Lancaster roofer market is.
Best suited to: those who own their home or commercial property and are looking to fix storm damage or have an exterior project beyond just roofing.
4. Greenawalt Roofing: Best for Residential and Commercial Flexibility
Greenawalt Roofing is a Lancaster-based family-owned company serving residential and commercial customers.
Repairing, replacement, new construction and storm damaged roofs are their specialties. They also provide siding and gutter services. They claim to have been in business since 2004. Although they have grown to cover other areas outside of Pennsylvania, they remain in Lancaster for their corporate headquarters.
The useful distinction here is property type.
Whether a homeowner needs a shingle replacement or a business owner is comparing commercial system contractors for a larger exterior project, Greenawalt works on both sides of that fence.
Best suited to: buyers looking for one roofing company for both residential and commercial projects that can coordinate siding or gutter work as well.
5. MR Roofing: Best for Roof-Focused Craftsmanship
MR Roofing is based in Manheim and has served the region since 1994.
The company constructs new roofs and also installs replacement roofs over homes and commercial buildings. Their website pays special attention to the details and craftsmanship of roofing.
That narrower focus can appeal to prospects who already understand that it is mostly about the roof.
MR Roofing also displays specialty details like copper details in addition to their mass replacement work. In some cases, especially when roof appearance & finishing touches matter, that specialized focus may be worth weighing against general exterior contractors.
Best suited to: homeowners or property owners seeking a roof-focused contractor who value installation detail.
How to Choose a Roofing Company in Lancaster PA
Roofing Services: Price Shouldn’t Be Your First (or Only) Filter when shopping around the options Pennsylvania homeowners have…
A stronger shortlist comes from asking a few practical questions:
- Repair or replacement? Seek a contractor who will explain why one option is preferable to the other.
- Residential or commercial? Do they primarily do both or focus more on one?
- Roof only or full exterior? Does the contractor offer siding and gutter services? This can come into play if storm damage has impacted multiple areas of the property.
- How is the project described? Photos, written scopes and clear communication can make bids easier to compare.
- Is the contractor licensed correctly? Pennsylvania’s HIC requirements are a good starting point before signing that home improvement contract.
Try using the decision rule of comparing proposed scope before comparing total price. Two estimates may appear similar but cover different aspects such as underlayment, flashing, ventilation, decking allowances or even cleanup.
That is where a detailed proposal becomes more useful than a headline number.
Final Verdict
There are trustworthy roofing companies in Lancaster. Of these five, each has its own niche client.
Joyland excels in explaining process. Exterior Company appears to be geared more towards bigger storm or exterior jobs. Greenawalt is flexible with both residential and commercial needs. MR Roofing is a go-to comparison for rigorous roof specific craftsmanship.
Roof Duck created the widest fitting shingles for Lancaster homeowners of the three.
Started in the local roofing industry back in 1947, their service lineup of inspections, repairs, replacements, siding and gutters today makes Roof Duck especially well-suited for homeowners looking for a proven local contractor who can handle not only the roof, but associated exterior work as well.
